The risks of relying on AI in employee disputes

14th Sep 2026

Author: Asim Din

When you are dealing with an employee dispute, it can be tempting to turn to AI for a quick answer. But how reliable is that answer when the legal position depends on the individual circumstances? Dispute Resolution Specialist Asim Din looks at the risks of relying on AI for legal guidance, from inaccurate information to confidentiality concerns.

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is becoming an everyday tool for businesses. It can draft emails, summarise documents and provide instant answers to questions.

But when that question is a legal one, particularly involving a dispute with an employee, relying too heavily on AI can be risky.

AI can be useful for general information, but it is not a substitute for tailored legal advice. Employment disputes are often complex and depend heavily on the specific facts of each case.

Just because it sounds plausible does not mean it is correct

One of the biggest risks with generative AI is that its answers can sound confident and authoritative, even when they are inaccurate.

AI tools can produce what are known as ‘hallucinations’, where information appears credible but is false. In a legal context, this can include incorrect references to legislation, outdated information or even cases which do not exist.

Employment law also changes regularly. An answer that sounds plausible is not necessarily one that is legally correct or up to date.

Every dispute is different

You might ask an AI tool whether you can dismiss an employee, how to respond to a grievance or what to do following an allegation of discrimination.

The difficulty is that the answer may change completely once the wider circumstances are understood. A Solicitor will consider the employee’s contract, length of service, previous events, the evidence available, whether the correct procedures have been followed and any wider issues which may affect the position.

Any one of those factors could change the advice. AI can only work with the information entered into it. It may not recognise that an important detail has been missed or know which questions need to be asked before a decision is made.

Getting it wrong can be costly

Employment disputes can escalate quickly. Any decision taken without considering all the relevant circumstances can make a difficult situation harder to resolve.

This is particularly important when dealing with disciplinary action, grievances, redundancy, discrimination allegations, dismissals and potential employment tribunal claims.

Seeking legal advice early can help you understand the risks and your options before taking action. It may also help resolve an issue before it becomes more costly, time-consuming and disruptive.

Confidentiality and data protection risks

Businesses should also think carefully about confidentiality. Employment disputes can involve sensitive personal and commercial information. Uploading contracts, correspondence or employee information into publicly available AI tools without understanding how that data will be handled may create confidentiality or data protection concerns.

AI is a tool, not a legal advisor

AI can be useful as a starting point for general information. The problem comes when businesses start treating that information as legal advice. Having a relationship with a Solicitor means you have someone who understands the law, but also your business and the particular circumstances you are facing. They can ask the right questions, identify risks you may not have considered and provide advice tailored to your situation.

If you are dealing with an employee dispute, considering disciplinary or dismissal action, responding to a grievance or facing another significant employment issue, taking advice at an early stage can help avoid costly mistakes.

At Butcher & Barlow, we provide clear, practical advice based on the individual circumstances of each case.

AI can give you an answer. Your Solicitor can help you understand whether it is the right one.

If you would like advice or wish to discuss a similar issue you can contact Asim in our Dispute Resolution Team on 01606 334309 or adin@butcher-barlow.co.uk.

Professional headshot of a Solicitor in a blue and white stripe shirt and dark suit jacket, standing in front of a grey background.

Asim Din

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Information in this article was correct at the time of publication. The information is for general guidance only. Laws and regulations may change, and the applicability of legal principles can vary based on individual circumstances. Therefore, this content should not be construed as legal advice. We recommend that you consult with a qualified legal professional to obtain advice tailored to your specific situation. For personalised guidance, please contact us directly.

    Make an enquiry