Winning the case: the commercial reality of litigation
23rd Oct 2026
Author: Asim Din
The long-running proceedings between Manchester City and the Premier League prompt a question for any business: even if you are right, is fighting to the end the commercial win you think it is? Asim Din considers why the legal position is only part of the decision when your business faces a dispute.
On 29 September 2026, the Premier League published an independent Commission’s findings of serious breaches of its financial rules over nine seasons. City strongly disputes those findings, maintains its innocence and lodged an appeal on 1 October 2026. The question of sanctions is being considered separately and the proceedings remain ongoing.
These disciplinary proceedings are distinct from an ordinary commercial court claim. The case is not a basis for second-guessing City’s appeal or the commercial considerations behind it. It is, however, a timely illustration of how lengthy a dispute can become.
For a closer look at the private dispute resolution process and potential compensation claims, read Tom Sedley’s article on the Manchester City case.
A legal win and a commercial win are not the same thing
A favourable judgment is one measure of success. For a business, cash flow, time and relationships matter too. A judgment in your favour may arrive years later, cost more than it recovers and leave a commercial relationship beyond repair.
The civil courts themselves aim to deal with cases fairly and at proportionate cost, weighing factors including the sums at stake, the expense and the parties’ resources. That is a useful yardstick for any business: alongside “can we win?”, ask “is winning worth what it costs?”
There is a human element to resolving a commercial dispute too. Once significant time and money have been committed, stepping back can feel like a concession. Businesses can become entrenched in fighting on principle until the original commercial objective becomes secondary to the need to be proved right.
Money already spent should not, by itself, justify spending more. Each further step should be assessed against its likely cost and benefit.
The costs you recover may not cover the costs you spend
A common misconception is that the loser pays everything. Although the general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs, the court retains discretion and different rules can apply depending on the claim. A successful party may still have substantial legal costs it cannot recover.
The way parties conduct the proceedings, including how they approach settlement opportunities, can also affect the costs position.
On top of that sit costs that never appear on a Solicitor’s bill: management time, lost focus and the time spent running a dispute instead of a business. There is also the practical question of enforcement. A judgment is not the same as money in the bank.
Settlement offers change the arithmetic
Settlement is not an admission of weakness. Formal settlement offers, including those made under Part 36 of the Civil Procedure Rules, can materially alter the costs risk depending on the offer and the eventual outcome. Part 36 sets out a formal process for making offers, with specific consequences for costs.
The practical message is that refusing an offer is itself a commercial decision. It should be assessed by reference to the likely net result, including costs and risks, rather than the desire to be vindicated.
Keep asking what the dispute is really for
The strongest discipline in dispute resolution is to keep returning to the original commercial objective. Was the aim to recover a debt, protect a brand, preserve a contract, prevent further harm or simply to be proved right?
Principles can matter, particularly where a business needs to protect its reputation or future position. But being proved right should not quietly replace the objective that justified bringing or defending the claim in the first place.
This matters because the assessment of your case can change. Documents exchanged during proceedings, witness evidence and expert opinion can all change the picture, sometimes sharply. A position that looked compelling at the outset may look very different a year later.
Equally, a strong legal case may no longer justify the cost of taking it to judgment. The evidence, risks and commercial objective should be revisited throughout the dispute, rather than allowing the original position, or money already spent, to dictate what happens next.
The question to keep asking is simple: does the next step still advance the result the business actually needs?
When to take advice
Early advice can help you assess your position before a disagreement becomes harder to resolve, particularly when you receive an offer to settle or an invitation to mediate.
Sometimes the right advice is to fight. On other occasions, a negotiated resolution is the better commercial outcome.
If your business is facing a dispute, speak to Asim Din in our Commercial Dispute Resolution Team. We can work with you to assess your options and agree an approach that reflects what matters most to your business.
Asim can be contacted at adin@butcher-barlow.co.uk or on 01606 334039. Alternatively complete our enquiry form.
Information in this article was correct at the time of publication. The information is for general guidance only. Laws and regulations may change, and the applicability of legal principles can vary based on individual circumstances. Therefore, this content should not be construed as legal advice. We recommend that you consult with a qualified legal professional to obtain advice tailored to your specific situation. For personalised guidance, please contact us directly.
